Failed electronic auction for 44 Federal Laws. The customer held an electronic auction, for which not a single application was submitted and the auction was declared invalid. How to reflect the repeated procedure in the schedule if the repeated auction will be carried out without

• Only 1 URZ submitted an application (see above).

• Only 1 URZ was admitted to the UAEF. His application was found compliant, the rest were rejected.

• Several URZs were admitted, but none of the URZs made bids at the auction. In this case, the winner is the URZ who submitted his application before everyone else. A contract is concluded with him.

• If the auction (OAEF) is declared invalid, then, depending on whether there is a participant admitted to it, the actions and documents drawn up are as follows.

• A protocol for declaring the electronic auction (OAEF) invalid is drawn up and posted on the site.

• This is a procedure that involves drawing up and posting a protocol on declaring the auction (OAEF) invalid.

• Reason for declaring the auction invalid: only 1 participant was admitted and/or declared.

• Information that a state agreement will be concluded with this participant. Contract.

• If there were other participants, but their applications were rejected, then the reasons for the rejection of applications are indicated.

• There is one participant.

• Concluding a contract with this participant.

• No participants or applications.

• Repeated auction.

• Replacement of an order.

• No applications.

• All applications (all URZ) were rejected.

• 1 participant allowed.

• There were no offers during the bidding.

Repeated auction in electronic form.

In this article I will focus on declaring the auction invalid.

When can this happen?

Firstly, if no applications were submitted for the auction at all, this is quite logical; what kind of auction is there if there is no one. What's next? Repeated bidding will be scheduled with a reduction in the initial price (NP) by 10% from the NC at the primary auction. If repeated ones do not take place, then tenders will be scheduled in the form of a public offer with a decrease in the NC.

The most interesting thing is not this.

Imagine this situation: you have decided to buy something from a primary or repeat auction (i.e. from an upward auction). You have submitted your application for electronic platform. And it just so happened that no one except you was allowed to participate in the auction, or no one submitted bids at all. What will happen in this case?

Now these auctions will be called invalid. But it’s too early to panic.

Even though this sounds sad, you, as the only participant in such auctions, will be recognized as the winner of the auction at the starting price. You applied for the auction at the starting price? It's not your problem that no one else applied or was admitted except you. You were ready to pay the initial price, because... for some reason you applied. Therefore, the auction organizer has no grounds, incl. Legislative laws do not designate you as the winner of such auctions.

What article of law are we relying on? Of course, to the main document - Federal Law No. 127 “On Insolvency”, or more precisely, paragraph 17 of Article 110 “Sale of the debtor’s enterprise” (download the Federal Law from the link)

“If only one participant was allowed to participate in the auction, whose application for participation in the auction complies with the conditions of the auction or contains an offer for the price of the enterprise not lower than the established initial sale price of the enterprise, the purchase and sale agreement for the enterprise is concluded by an external manager with this participant in the auction”

So if you sole participant auction and your application with its Appendices comply, you can count on the fact that you bought the item at the starting price.

This is how things stand with the recognition of trades as invalid.

Therefore, when I showed in my video tutorial these auctions for the purchase of a plot of land in the city of Yartsevo from some attentive readers our newsletter, there was a fair bewilderment: “How is he telling us here that he bought the land, but the auction didn’t take place?”

That’s how they “didn’t happen”!

And this is a certificate of ownership of that same plot of land. This is Anyone who has access to the Sberbank-AST platform can also view the trading procedure - SBR013-1404110020

Sometimes customers have to recognize the auction as invalid. What to do if the auction did not take place, because not a single application was submitted under 44-FZ, we will show in the article.

Consequences of declaring an auction invalid

Having analyzed Art. 71 of Law 44-FZ, there are two reasons why the electronic auction did not take place:

• no application has been submitted;
• one application has been submitted.

To obtain full access to the PRO-GOSZAKAZ.RU portal, please register. It won't take more than a minute. Select social network for quick authorization on the portal:

The further actions of the contract managers will depend on the reason why the competitive procedure was declared invalid:

• if there are no applications, carry out a new purchase;
• if one application is submitted, draw up a government contract with the participant who submitted it.

Conclusion of a contract with a single supplier when the auction did not take place

In cases where:

• the application of one participant has been submitted (part 16 of article 66);
• after analyzing the first parts of the submitted applications, only one of the participants who submitted their applications was allowed to participate in the procedure (Part 8 of Article 67);
• the second part of the submitted application of only one of the participants in the procedure satisfies the procurement conditions (Part 13 of Article 69); a contract is drawn up with the person who submitted it.

The only condition will be that a single application meets all stated requirements.

Another reason for such a contract is a combination of circumstances when none of the admitted participants e-procurement did not send his offer with a price within ten minutes from the moment it began (part 20 of article 68).

Imagine the situation: no applications were submitted to the competition, only one application was submitted, or only one application meets the documentation requirements. In all cases, you must declare the competition invalid. But what to do next if you are not ready to cancel the purchase depends on the number of applications.
If the competition failed due to the fact that no one submitted a single application, you need to act on one option. And if you yourself have rejected all applications, you must act completely differently. And then, when you start receiving new applications, new conditions will be included each time depending on the quantity and quality of applications. Let us explain how to choose the right procurement method under different conditions.

From the article

Clause 25, Part 1, Art. 93 of the Law on the Constitutional Court establishes the rules of what to do under 44-FZ if the purchase did not take place when a contract was concluded with a single supplier:

• execute a government contract on the terms specified in the procurement documentation at a price not exceeding the starting price of the auction;
• the registration period should not exceed 20 days from the date of publication of the final protocol.

Important

In this case, signing a contract with sole supplier is not subject to approval by the FAS and other control authorities.

The electronic auction did not take place because... no applications

In accordance with part 4 of Art. 71 procedures did not take place if:

• not a single application has been submitted under 44-FZ (Part 16, Article 66);
• there is no admission of any of the participants who submitted such an application (Part 8 of Article 67);
• all second parts of applications were compiled incorrectly (part 13 of article 69);
• participant who proposed Better conditions after the winner, avoided signing a government contract and refused to formalize such a contract (Part 15, Article 70).

If not a single application has been submitted for the auction under 44-FZ, what to do next? Should be announced repurchase.

An electronic auction was held for the supply of wooden coffins. No one submitted a bid, so the auction was declared invalid. Now we want to try a request for proposals, but Law No. 44-FZ does not directly indicate whether we have the right to change the terms of the purchase. Can we reduce the NMCC, add an advance payment condition, change the delivery time?

If no bids are submitted for the auction

44-FZ in part 4 art. 71 contains the answer to the question of what to do next in this case:

• carry out repeated procurement, the method of which from July 1, 2018 can only be an electronic request for proposals. Until this time, the Law on contract system allows you to carry out another procedure (for example, repeated auctions are often held);
• the item of re-purchase cannot be changed from the original;
• reintroduce a new competitive procedure into the schedule.

If the re-auction did not take place - not a single application was submitted - what to do under 44-FZ? Until July 1, 2018, you can hold the 3rd auction or request for proposals or apply another competitive procedure within the framework of the Law on the Contract System.

If the auction did not take place 2 times, what should I do in this case? From July 1, 2018, this issue will no longer exist, because... new edition Part 4 Art. 71 The law obliges re-purchase in the form electronic request proposals. If the request for proposals does not take place, the government customer makes changes to the schedule and conducts another purchase.

Thus, the answer to the question: not a single application has been submitted for the auction; what next will be: to carry out a repeat purchase, and from July 1, 2018 only in the form of an electronic request for proposals.

You will find more answers to questions about procurement in the new issue of the magazine “Government Order in Questions and Answers”

Sometimes, for a number of reasons, an electronic auction under 44-FZ may not take place (more precisely, it will be declared failed).

1. The auction did not take place if there was only one participant
In this case, the customer enters into a contract with this participant as the winner, provided that the second part of the application meets the established requirements under 44-FZ and auction documentation. Coordination with regulatory authorities in in this case is not required, since according to the conditions, one application is sufficient for quorum, if it is completed correctly. Naturally, if you refuse, you will be held liable as if you had participated in a full-fledged tender with many participants and won it. If you submitted a single application, and it did not pass, the customer must hold a new auction.

2. The auction did not take place if there were several participants
a) Let’s assume that there are several participants in an electronic auction, but only one of them meets the requirements for the second part of the application. Accordingly, in this case the rule of paragraph “1” is applicable, that is, the government customer enters into a contract with this participant without approval from the regulatory authority.
b) There are several participants in the auction, but the government customer rejected all applications at the stage of consideration of the second parts. The solution is to hold new auctions.

3. No bids have been submitted (there are no participants in the auction)

According to Part 4 of Art. 71 44-FZ, the customer can make a request for proposals for the auction. As part of a request for proposals after a failed auction, it is prohibited, however, to change the procurement object (however, it is formally possible, but not recommended, to change its cost, as well as the deadlines). The notice to the Unified Information System must be submitted by the customer no later than 5 days (calendar) before the day of the request for proposals. At the same time, according to 44-FZ, the customer has the right to independently send invitations to participate in the procurement process to those persons who, in his opinion, are capable of fulfilling the terms of the contract. However, in this case, these persons must be indispensable counterparties of the customer for at least 18 months before the date of request for similar supplies.

4. The auction did not take place if all applications were rejected at the stage of consideration of the first parts
In theory this is hardly possible, but in reality electronic trading Anything can happen. Accordingly, in this case the previous paragraph on the request for proposals is applicable. If, of all applications, based on the results of consideration of the first parts (and not the second), only one participant is admitted, then, according to Part 2 of Article 71, the problem is resolved by approval from the regulatory body.

5. The auction did not take place because none of the participants came to it
According to Part 3 of Article 71, the problem is resolved by approval from the regulatory authority (the first application that meets the conditions of the auction). If no application matches, or the application matches, but the participant is ready for termination, then the clause applicable under the terms of 44-FZ is applied:

"3. If the electronic auction is declared invalid on the grounds provided for in Part 20 of Article 68 of this Federal Law due to the fact that within ten minutes after the start of such an auction, none of its participants submitted a proposal for the contract price:

4) the contract is concluded in accordance with paragraph 25 of part 1 of Article 93 of this Federal Law in the manner established by Article 70 of this Federal Law, with a participant in such an auction, the application for participation in which was submitted:

a) earlier than other applications for participation in such an auction, if several participants in such an auction and the applications submitted by them are recognized as complying with the requirements of this Federal Law and the documentation on such an auction.”